Fall 2025 - 3
What is the author conveying through the symbol of the black birds?
In “Mr Green”, Butler shows through the explanation of black birds how traditional beliefs place a barrier in the ideal role in feminine society, along with prioritizing dominance of womenhood by manhood.
While the narrator reminisces about her experience with grandpa in the bird market, she recalls how grandpa used to assess the black birds: “... Like they were fools to be only content with their own company.” This quote shows that Grandpa was less content with birds that were independent on their own. The birds in this story symbolize feminine society; therefore, from this quote, we can see that Grandpa, or the traditional Confucian society, devalued women who had an outgoing personality, who did not need to be needed by anyone. Independent women were constrained by social norms and values made by traditional beliefs.
While looking at more birds, the narrator noticed that Grandpa bought some sparrows for culinary purposes. “Why aren’t they flying? I asked. “Their wings are clipped.” In this context, with their wings clipped, the sparrows could not resist being put into a separate box. They have no freedom, which represents the women’s social stance in the traditional society. Men have all the social needs to incarcerate women into what men want them to be, just like how sparrows in this story cannot fly outside the box while being bought for food.