WritingLong analysis
Long analysis — 2026

Winter 2025 - Final essay

What is Ellison conveying about identity as a whole through the narrator's repeated adoption of various communities, from model student in college to worker in the North to spokesman for the Brotherhood?

Throughout the Narrator’s journey in The Invisible Man, Ellison conveys that true identity cannot be discovered by suiting with external communities, but found in distorted and seemingly invisible periods, which can be filled with harshness but also full of self-discovery. Also, the Narrator’s experiences furthermore emphasizes the message that an individual being cannot be defined as a single word.

By explaining the Narrator’s early student days, Ellison shows the fact that freedom of identity cannot be achieved by choosing to adapt with the expectations that follows up people in the confined society. During his speech infront of white people after the barbaric battle royale, he remarks their ignorance of his speech as: “I spoke even louder in spite of the pain. But still they talked and still they laughed, as though deaf with cotton in dirty ears.” The Narrator, being black, has set his viewpoint to adapt, choosing to impress white people in a way to upgrade his power and be successful, initially wanting freedom. He had delivered this speech in intensions to get White people’s attention, only for them to ignore it. This represents how people, especially minorities, initially cannot split themselves from the sense of prejudice. The Narrator’s speech symbollizes that no matter good or bad, minority’s cannot exceed the barrier to a point that they get treated the same as majoritys. While with the vet, Mr Norton, a negro college teacher who is determined for his education explains: “I felt, and I still feel, that your people are in some important manner tied to my destiny.” While his mission, seemingly, is to empower the black race, by this quote, Mr Norton’s ‘destiny’ is to educate them. This tells us that Mr Norton is a figure whos desire is initially centering himself, not for the black people. Although the Narrator tries to look good infront of Mr Norton, he treats the race like a tool. This also represents that although Black people often try, they initially cannot step up to a position where they gain power, as initially, whites control blacks, meaning that adapted minority’s identity is being held by the majority’s.

During the Narrator’s time working in New York, Ellison steps up by explaining that identity comes from the sense of individuality, being dependent from the society’s impressions. When the Narrator sees Hot fried pies while walking down the street, he exclaims: “I would probably have indigestion if I ate one—now that I no longer felt ashamed of the things I had always loved, I probably could no longer digest very many of them.” Hot pies, being a southern food, was counted by the Northern community as distasteful and awkward. Narrator explains that in his entire phase he has been judged by his individual beliefs by other people, trying to adapt to the community as best as possible to get included. This quote, therefore, represents that the feeling to be accepted actually pushs away who they actually were. To extend, by the Narrator finding out his real self, Ellison conveys that breaking the expectation rather than to follow it is the first step towards individualism. During a street eviction, the Narrator remarks his emotions: “I wanted to leave, but was too ashamed to leave, was rapidly becoming too much a part of it to leave.” For his entire life, he was trained to preserve himself from the society’s expectations. However, seeing others doing nothing towards this moment of injustice has shifted the Narrator, as society’s expectations has blinded the community against injustice and security of individuality. This tells us that individual identity being surpassed by expectations of this society is bringing people to injustice by the majority instead of fighting against it.

Finally, throughout the Narrator’s experiences at the Brotherhood, Ellison conveys that communities that tie between common individuality rather surpasses and denys identity for the organization’s good, while ignoring and sometimes sacrificing identity. After the delivery of the Narrator’s freestyle oratory, the other brothers critisice him: “It was the antithesis of the scientific approach. Ours is a reasonable point of view.” Rather than feeling, the Brotherhood chooses to follow the path of logics. While the Narrator’s speech was based on his ingenuity and experiences, the brotherhood seems to ignore those motions brought in by him, which tells that the organization is far from being a genuine human organization. This furthermore symbollizes that identity at a course of group which prioritises individuality often gets overlooked by the structure of it, getting denied by the reality, bringing themselves into a world filled without knowing what living really means, staying ignorant under the barrier of a group. When Ras, an activist, interrupts the Brotherhood at Harlem, he leaves a remark: “They hate you, mahn. You African. AFRICAN! Why you with them? Leave that shit, mahn. They sell you out. ” Ras identifies the organization as a traitor to the black community, since they get interfered by white people, whom they can pretend that they are inclusive, but initially devided by the barrier of race. This quote shows that concept of undeniable barrier is being overlooked by the feeling of acceptance. People, rather than knowing their place in the world, is being suited in a confined space where conformity takes control rather than individuality. While they are being accepted, they often either ignore the fact that they are vulnerable over the majority of the society, or fight for their own positions rathethan achieving greater things. Therefore, Ras’s exclamation warns to us that communal groups blind us from identifying and discovering ourselves, choosing to be comfortable with being accepted whilst they are the ones in vulnerability.

    base44
    Edit with Base44